Listen and Learn Musical Expertise!
Dr. George Sawa:Egyptian Music Appreciation & Practice for Bellydancers
CD Review by Zumarrad
posted September 9, 2010
Many Belly dancers are lucky to live in areas with vibrant Arabic music scenes, where they can experience first-hand the instruments and musical forms that shape our dancing. However, many more of us are not. George Sawa’s CD set is an ideal resource for anyone in this situation, and should become a favourite of dance teachers and serious students.
This is not going to become your favourite listening or dancing CD set, but that is not the point. The selections are there to put theory into practice; they’re simple, short, and straightforward and their purpose seems to be to train your ear, not to induce tarab!
The idea is to listen, learn, and use the clips to get the rhythms, in particular, into your body through free dance practice. If used to the fullest, this resource will give you a wonderful grounding in Egyptian music.
It contains examples of 21 rhythms and eight maqams: short clips demonstrating the sounds of the non-Western percussive and melodic instruments that we can expect to hear on our Egyptian musical journeys, and musical excerpts, incorporating all of these things. The CDs are packaged in a sturdy, attractive and usable booklet – this is a resource you can carry easily to class with you.
The booklet really makes the resource valuable because it’s extensively and meticulously cross-referenced. The rhythms are written out in Western-style notation, which is very useful if you have that kind of musical training, syllabic notation (dum rest takk takk) and in traditional Arabic circle form. This last type of notation is really helpful. The idea is to listen to the rhythm track and tap the rhythm around the circle. It’s a very different way to learn and a lot of fun. The maqams are written as letter scales and in Western-style notation, which makes it very easy to determine which ones might work on Western instruments and which are impossible without retuning. (Ajam is C major. Who knew?) This approach is very good for someone like me who learns best with a combination of audio and visual information.
A chapter on musical instruments, which includes colour photographic illustrations, is also invaluable to the more isolated dancer. Many of these instruments are ones we will never see played in real life locally. I feel a bit like an eight year old using it, but it’s really helpful looking at the picture of the instrument as it plays!
Because almost all of CD1 is comfortably set out with straight rhythm clips followed by examples of the rhythm being used in a song – excellent for drilling, though it would be even better if they were all roughly the same length; the lack of similar examples following each maqam on CD2 feels a little disconcerting. However, each maqam is represented in song on the set; you just have to find it, usually on the other CD.
I like spoon-feeding, and in an ideal world, I’d love to hear the maqam also played as a scale, followed by the song clip. I figure the ear connection would be made more quickly that way, but I can also see that this would not be practical. In fact, it is best not to think of this as a two-CD set but rather a singular musical study course that (unfortunately) doesn’t fit on one CD. It seems pretty clear that the only reason this resource comes on two CDs is because you can’t get a single CD readily that will fit 110 minutes of music.
I would also have liked it if the maqam descriptions were a little deeper because there’s no information about how they traditionally connect to particular emotions, or why they are named the way they are.
Dr. Sawa was classically trained in Egypt, but I’m also sure there are musicians who will follow other naming conventions, and some Belly dancers may not like his assertion that dancers should stick with two simple zill patterns and leave the rhythmic flash to the drummer. I like the way Dr. Sawa recommends other CDs, DVDs, and websites where you can learn more, and these sources are not all his own output, either.
Rating: 3 1/2 zils
Product purchase info:
Have a comment? Use or comment section at the bottom of this page or Send us a letter!
Check the "Letters to the Editor" for other possible viewpoints!
Ready for more?
- 7-15-10 Sema Yildiz, A Star of Turkish Dance
She was fortunate, she says, to grow up in a Roma (Gypsy) community rich in dance and music – the Fatih district, which houses the Sulukule, famous for its entertainment and considered the oldest Roma settlement in the world.
- 3-18-10 Not Last Year’s Saiidi
Recently, a belly dance community newsletter here in New Zealand ran an editorial in which the author remarked that the current generation of dancers still perform “traditional styles – Ghwazee, Khaleegy, Saiidi” but innovate with poi, fan veils and Isis wings in a sort of dance evolution that retains respect for the value of the old.
- 1-11-03 Music to My Ears, How I Learned to Hear Like a Dancer
Musical interpretation is the single, most important skill that can elevate the Oriental dancer from the chorus line to the spotlight.
- 10-22-02 A Story Written with Arabic Idioms; Why it is Difficult to Translate Arabic songs into English, Story by Annonymous, Translations and interpretations by Rima El-Mouzayen,
“just try to read it in English and at the same time, think in Lebanese Arabic…if you can! "
- The Gilded Serpent Magical Musical Tour of Instruments!
- 3-20-06 Leyla Jouvani’s DVD 21 shimmies and 1001 variations Review by Monet
An IAMED production. I would recommend this video. This video is very long at about 2 hours and 15 minutes running time. You certainly get your monies worth.
- 8-17-10 And I thought I Knew Him, Horacio Cifuentes: Confessions of a Male Belly Dancer Book Review by Amina Goodyear
Yes, I thought I knew Horacio Cifuentes, a San Francisco dancer who moved to Berlin to be with and wed Beata Zadou. After reading his book, I realized I really did not know him. The book, “Confessions of a Male Belly Dancer”, is exactly that. It is a self-produced autobiography written in a very sincere, almost shockingly honest way. It is personal and personable.
- 8-17-10 Tribal Videos Today, Tribal Fusions, Volume 2 from Bellydance Superstars
Tales of Desire from Hollywood Music Reviewed by Davina
It’s my belief, that as dancers, it’s good to keep up with what’s happening within the greater dance community, even if it doesn’t suit our taste or style. It’s especially important for dance instructors to recognize who the industry leaders are. It doesn’t matter if it’s Egyptian Raks Sharki or Flamenco/Gypsy/Zambra Mora or in this case, Tribal Fusion–knowing who is the current crème-de-la-crème will give you a stronger knowledge base from which to teach your students. Investing in one or two high-quality professionally made Tribal DVDs will add breadth to a dancers video collection.
- 7-16-10 Fusing Jazz with Middle Eastern, Souren’s "Taksim, It’s About Time" and Vince’s "Beginnings", Two CDs Reviewed by Amina Goodyear
However, in all reality, now in this world when we fuse a Belly dance with everything as well as the kitchen sink (pots, spoons, mop handles, bowls, vases, trays) why not consider seriously performing to one or both of these Jazz fusion CDs played by some of the most respected Middle Eastern musicians in the field? If dancers perform already with fusion music, why not use music that is specifically fusion?
Sep 25, 2010 - 07:09:40
Great review – I just bought this today at workshop thanks to your review (well, that and Bozenka’s recommendation as well.)