Gilded Serpent presents...

Debunking the “Golden Age” of Bellydance, Part 1

Najia

by Najia Marlyz
posted August 29, 2011

Do you feel all dressed up with no place to dance?  Then, nothing has changed much in the last four decades of Bellydance opportunities, except our dancers’ expectations.

Perhaps, those of us who learned to perform back in the day, speak about the Bellydance phenomenon now as if it were some sort of “Golden Age” for dancers, (Privately–maybe! Collectively, let me assure you: it was not.)

When most people become involved in a specific form of dance for the first time, aspirations for the future use of that art or skill seldom enter the prospective dancer’s mind, at least, in the beginning. The same circumstances were true for me, too. At the end of the 1960s, when I embarked on my new Raqs Sharqi dance adventure, I thought of dance as a healthy, artistic, and constructive activity for my mind and body as well as a place to use my other (more important, I thought) artistic endeavors.

Specifically, my interests became centered on the creative re-use of textiles, especially antique laces and fabrics such as velvets and sheer silk chiffon that have little use in normal, everyday living.  It was my intention to learn the art of dance performance because it was the rage du jour, and it would offer me a valid excuse to use my abilities to repair and recycle vintage garments as well as detailed pieces of hand-work from decades past (such as Victorian times and the Roaring ‘20s), incorporating them into my dance costuming.  

Along with my goal of recycling and renewing vintage clothing, jewelry and other objects, I hoped to use my knowledge to widen my typically cloistered world as a young, childless married woman in an urban Northern California locale. I had been fulfilling simply what was usually expected of women back then: namely, running a household, dabbling in the arts, and getting on with domestic life —just  like everyone else of the era. We were singing the song that was new in 1963, which became Pete Seeger’s hit recording, “Boxes! Little Boxes, all made out of ticky-tacky…”  Yes, it was the ‘60s, but I had found a way to make something new, sparkling and fascinating out of forgotten things that were beautiful, handmade, and old rather than new and made of “ticky-tacky”. Granted, that took place for me four decades ago, but circumstances of employment via Bellydancing have not changed that much within our dance community, even now.

It occurs to me that we dancers of the ’60s and ’70s (inadvertently) may have misled today’s beginning professional dancers into believing that we danced in the spotlight of fabulous stages on the bill with the rich and famous while they seem destined (and doomed) to dance their frenetic foreshortened versions of the Bellydance before each other at parties and for strangers and friends in restaurants. Sometimes, I wonder if we are secretly motivated by the perverse schadenfreude of watching them fight over our imaginary crumbs! Perhaps, we long-time professionals should accept some of the blame for helping them lower their expectations concerning their prospects of finding a place to perform once they have perfected their art well enough to turn professional.

At the same time, we are sounding authoritarian and sometimes overly pedantic about how much remuneration one might rightfully demand for a public Bellydance performance. The fact of the matter for us was that often we had had to manufacture our own opportunities to dance where there were none previously; perhaps we have preferred to make the situation look hopeless nowadays in order to stay in control (or to believe that we are).

Some of us earned actual money over the years, but our naughty little secret is that (literally) sometimes Bellydancers were hungry hippies and flower-children of the ’60s, and they danced for tokes, onions, strings of beads and sometimes, nothing.

Most of us grew out of it and lived to tell the tale.  We may have become too complacent in our perceived empire (now called the Bellydance community) that we built a long time ago out of mud, straw, and wild ethnic/Orientalist fantasies. It was there that we found our secret "back door into showbiz"! (Sparkle, sparkle, sparkle!)

For us, it became clear: there was next-to-nowhere to perform as a professional Bellydancer even then, but that did not stop us! However, our circumstances were easily changed because we were entering untested waters: There were no traditions or preset standards that we were compelled to meet. We set about creating our own opportunities –some for pay, some not.  Then, quel horrore! Those monetary practicalities of over-head, expenses, and maintaining the dance venues that we had created or secured for ourselves concerning some of our most popular and successful experiments began to seep into our reality. We had created festivals, pageants, belly-grams, and showcases for Bellydancers, but then found that when planning these activities and events, we had to make progressively less time available per dancer so that we could pack more warm bodies into our shows and events because they usually brought along with the dancers, their corresponding, ticket-buying fans –just to satisfy our burgeoning overhead. We learned about "show-biz economics" the hard way!  It was a sobering moment that almost brought us back to earth.

nylonsThe era was certainly not a golden age for American women in general, either, by any stretch of the imagination! However, our surge toward feminism could not be thwarted quite so easily. Our fascination with Oriental dance was “gold-toned” around the edges if not pure gold; it promised and delivered absolute satisfaction – of experiment and creativity, if not dollars.  We intended to re-invent ourselves into "a new kind of independent woman" at a time when it was important to keep the seams of your nylon stockings straight up the back of your leg (held in place by the irritating gizmo called the “garter belt” or that other odd torture-device called the "latex girdle”).

Flower-children and assorted hippies were singing “Kumbayah” in the streets of Berkeley and burning their bras, while most of us were just enjoying a sigh of relief from trashing the hated garter belt in favor of the terribly expensive new invention called… “pantyhose".

A pair of pantyhose in the ‘60s cost about twenty to thirty dollars per pair; in today’s money, that was more than an average grade school teacher (which was my chosen profession) earned in one day, teaching 36 (yes, thirty-six!) children per each classroom. Though it may seem peculiar now, the invention of pantyhose, alone, was a giant step forward for freedom and comfort of modern womankind. I wore out many of them two decades later while dancing on-stage, but nowadays, dancers seldom wear such things as pantyhose anymore, preferring bare legs, torn tights, or too many skirts. I think the garment has become almost as strange as bloomers and tightly-cinched, boned corsets.

Nevertheless, there was a larger question brewing for women in the movement almost everyone called “Feminism”. Bellydancing in America hit an unprecedented popularity in many American women’s lives –especially on both coasts, starting in the East.

In general, our motivation was not related to money; therefore, it was not related to getting a job as a performing dancer (although some considered it a test of one’s mettle as a fine dancer).  Instead, we needed to free ourselves first and consider practicalities later.

Bert posterBert Fire eatingMany of today’s instructors have given the impression to young professionals (who are now just entering show business) that there were all kinds of venues and opportunities in which to dance back in the day, and that potential audiences and employers were impatiently waiting for us to finish learning to dance so that they could hire us. Oh! How we wished it had been so! The fact remains hidden that some of today’s name movers and shakers never (or seldom) moved or shook on any stages or in any spotlights; they did not actually perform (at least, not solo) for a paycheck.  Therefore, some teachers of the performance art called American Cabaret Bellydance are not,  themselves, versed in either stage craft or solo performance, but they won’t tell you that and, for some reason of polite deferece, you don’t ask!  

Just like today, dancers had to create the place, the time, and the excuse to show or “sell” our newly-found artistry or resign ourselves to dance in parks and on street-corners or in syncopated troupe dances forever. So much for creativity and self-expression…

Fortunately, my mentor, the late Bert Balladine, a.k.a. Roman Balladine, had worked show venues such as Vaudeville, the circus, and smoky nightclubs as well as the cabarets of Europe as an entertainer, performing Adagio, Tap, and Acrobatic dancing, along with his infamous fire-eating act. Bert was among the early pioneers of Bellydance, bringing it to America and re-introducing it to Europeans, too.  Those few Bellydance pioneers such as Bert found a clientèle that had become increasingly reluctant to pay much for entertainers, but employers would often deign to pay for a “Bellydancer” because the dance form was considered unusual, rarely seen in the US, and was absolutely more exotic than the existing stage entertainment then available.

As Bert was fond of saying to those who attempted to clean up the reputation of our dance form:

“The image of Bellydance must stay a little bit naughty to the general public, because when it isn’t anymore, they’ll look for something else.”

To the people who were hoping to book entertainment, Bellydancing was only one baby-step away from actually being what was referred to as “exotic dance”, “stripping”, or "side-show hoochy-koutchy" and most of us struggled violently against that impression.

Just like today, Bellydancers were “all dressed up with no place to go”.  Before the ‘60s, there were precious few formal Bellydance lessons, except for tentative six-week courses in Bellydancing at the YMCA or YWCA or city recreation departments in large cities.  There were no Bellydance lessons offered in most variety dance studios, either, except for studios like Berkeley’s Denishawn Studio where Ruth St. Denis enjoyed the exotic kutch dance and other ethnic dances. Those who tried to include Bellydance found that it was unwelcome in most dance studios because of its stigma. If not being thought of as obscene, it was, at least, considered tawdry and low-class by dancers who were involved in other dance forms.

Ruth St DenisMy goal was to teach Bellydance in a college setting, but I quickly learned that my teaching certificate and my Master’s degree was insufficient for my being hired.  The administration officers informed me that I would have to teach one of the Physical Education Department’s instructors to dance so that she could, in turn, teach the course because my master’s degree and my teaching certificate had been earned with the wrong academic major subjects (i.e. not in the Physical Education department).

When I opened my first dance studio in Albany, California, I overheard two women on the sidewalk, peeking in the studio window, saying sadly, “Well, there goes our neighborhood…”

Generally, professional dancers had to build contacts among musicians who were part of bands and orchestras, because recorded music of the day sounded tinny and uninspiring. Realistic recordings for Bellydance simply did not exist. Extremely few Middle Eastern musicians had come to America to play until the ’60s. Even then, those who came did not come here to be a musician in a nightclub or restaurant, and they usually had a day job like house painter, restaurateur, or used car and insurance policy salesmen while some used it as a way to put themselves through a college education.  Getting a visa and buying a ticket to America was not feasible for most foreign professional musicians. Some who played here were amateur musicians at best.  Did you imagine that American orchestras and live bands played Middle Eastern music even as recently as 30 or 40 years ago?  No! However, most American bands could manage to play Fiddler on the Roof”, "Hava Nagila" “Green Eyes”, “Stardust”, and “Ahab the Arab”, and orchestras could play “In an Persian Market”, but that was about it! A dancer’s taqsim might be performed to a rendition of "Born Free".

Since it is central to our dance, music has been at the appreciable forefront of technological change for us.

Some things in the world do change with the passage of time and, sometimes, we dancers are compelled to change with them. Almost imperceptibly, technological changes also change us and our attitudes as we begin to embrace those new technologies.

We dancers have beautifully recorded music now –almost at our beck and call. Those vinyl recordings that were once so dear to us dancers, now sound scratchy and outdated, and the video tape cassettes of the eighties are terribly painful to watch because of their lack of resolution. 

You may often hear dancers of the early days express their heart-felt opinion that "you were not a real dancer if you were not dancing to live music" but the reality of the situation was that doing a gig that could accommodate the space and cost of a group of Middle Eastern musicians was not easily available. Many times, professional American dancers performed with live music that was so "homemade" that it was virtually laughable to call it music! However, if you take the trouble to listen and watch films and videos of early dancers on occasion (and get your brain past the cacophony they called their “live music”) you will find accomplished dancers performing and innovating with their dance. What the composers wrote, recorded in scratchy vinyl, remains not only valid but challenging, and the dance movements are as captivating then as now.

What has changed most, (other than the piling on of excessive spacial movement–sometimes called “use of stage”, folk-dance steps, and too many overly-complex dance movement combinations) are minor peripheral dance issues: hair styles and musical arrangements, beads vs. coin use, shoes/no shoes and other notions about what makes for reasonable authenticity and what makes memorable artistry. Imagine how dated, irrelevant, and off-putting today’s Disco-Mixes and Steam-Punk sounds and images will be in ten or twenty years!

Part Two–Debunking the Golden Age: Finding Gigs

use the comment box

Have a comment? Use or comment section at the bottom of this page or Send us a letter!
Check the "Letters to the Editor" for other possible viewpoints!

Ready for more?

  • Get Over It! Soundbyte Bellydance Part Two
    Imagine yourself dancing inside of a huge plastic jug full of gel or detergent. Pull and push your movements through the viscosity with conviction!
  • Sound-Byte Bellydance, Part One: Evolution of Bellydance
    Through her clear description of what she wanted to learn, I was able to look inside our recent dance evolution and see what we dance teachers in the west have done to change Bellydance here in the U.S., how we have changed and modified it into something it never was in the lands of its origins.
  • Teacher or Coach: What’s the Difference? Why All Performing Dancers Need a Dance Coach
    Most performers have a great deal of untapped potential; additionally, many consider it cheating to engage a professional coach and yet, that is exactly what they would look for if this were the Olympics and they were competing for the gold!
  • Improvisation: Method Behind the Madness
    One of the biggest mistakes we western Bellydancers have made is presuming that the dancing to which Arabs refer as the “Eastern Dance” is a theatrical dance that ought to be choreographed as if it were a ballet, or that its steps and movements are traditional like those of the Greek Hasapiko, an Arabic Depke, or a Hawaiian Hula.
  • The Dance Teacher: By Divine Design or Default?
    …nearly everywhere, dancers in this particular form seem to have found it necessary to “do it all” in order to earn a living by dance career alone
  • I Walk In Pain And Beauty
    I also walk with the Hope that other dancers will read this and know that they don’t balance on this double-edged sword alone.
  • The Skinny on Abdominal Strengthening
    You’ve probably heard the terms neutral spine and core balance being bandied about, and seen numerous class offerings for Pilates, body ball, and core workouts. You may be wondering, is this the sort of thing you should be checking out?
  • Journey into Womanhood
    Our mission, as women, is to encourage others to joyfully anticipate all the decades of their lives. Those who have gone before us have always and will always help us on our paths.
  • Improving Breathing for Better Dance Performance
    We also hold our breath when we concentrate or get nervous. This brings tension into our bodies. The more tension we have, the more shallow we breathe. It can become a vicious circle!
  • The Constant Grind
    Today, the bitter truth is that the curvaceous and fleshy female figure is constantly disrespected by the media and pop culture.
  • Got Strength? Buffing up for Bellydance
    Muscles are like smart-aleck teenagers. If you ask them to do something, they do just enough to get the job done—and no more.
  • Belly Dance Secrets for Fitness and Rejuvenation
    The most important factor in sustaining an exercise program is the ‘fun factor’; Belly dancing comes with great music, exciting moves, noisy coin belts and its own special dress code.
  • NIA: A JOURNEY IN MIND and BODY FITNESS
    I believe that I am on a fascinating journey and that on of the destinations is the path, itself.
  • Dancing on the Roof of the World, Community Festival in Tajikistan .
    After all my many travels to Tajikistan, filled with the frantic bustle of dance lessons, rehearsals, teaching, doing trip logistics, hunting for traditional bits and bobs for costuming, and getting fitted for stage costumes, I finally decided to try being a more-or-less normal tourist in one of my favorite places on Earth, the Pamir mountains of Badakhshan, eastern Tajikistan.
  • Serpent Tour 2011 Journal- London, Madrid and Marrakech!
    An experimental travel blog. Let see how it goes! The plan is to update this page frequently.
  • Photos from Rakkasah West 2011, Sunday A- L
    Adira, Anisa, Ashley Lopez, Orchids, Damascus, Danielle, Desert Dream, Diana, Dondi, Dancers of the Desert, El Asaab, Evangaline, Fahtiem, Fatima, Ghawazee, Alexandria, Jamilla, Joweh, Karavansary, Lisa
  • The Transformation of Beauty, Inverting the Gaza, Part 3
    As women and performers, why cannot we see beyond physical representation, when we, too, are trying our hardest to achieve such beauty in our own lives? Such hypocrisy ensures that we can never escape the limitations that society and, thus, we place these same limitations upon our own bodies.

   |       |    7 Comments

  1. No Gravatar
    Kamala Almanzar

    Aug 30, 2011 - 12:08:56

    Maybe Najia started a little earlier than I did, hence the different experience, or maybe No Cal didn’t have quite as big a scene. I guess I was lucky because LA & London in the late ’70s & early ’80s were Middle Eastern entertainment boomtowns. Thinking of the LA clubs to choose from (& I’m sure I don’t remember all) 7th Veil, Ali Baba’s, Abu Nawas, Koko’s, Greek Village, Athenean Gardens, The Gypsy, The Grape Stakes, Sayat Nova, Darvish, The Crossbow, Haji Baba’s (Inglewood, Hollywood), Aegean Isles, The Fez, Cabaret Tehran, Omar Kahyam, Colbeh, Sahara, Burger Continental, Stox II, and I’ll bet I’m forgetting about 10 others. There were 1 to 3 dancers a night (I think Koko’s even had about 10 some nights including Tanhoura, Khaleegi & Saiidi group numbers). 6 nights a week usually. That was a ton of work for dancers, and that’s not even including Orange County. And London – well there was a ton there too. BTW all of the above had live music as well.

  2. No Gravatar
    Barbara Grant

    Aug 30, 2011 - 01:08:21

    Excellent article, Najia, and nice point by Kamala. I can see I’ll really enjoy this discussion, not having been involved in the art much before 1990.

  3. No Gravatar
    Najia

    Sep 1, 2011 - 01:09:47

    Yes, Kamala, the era I was writing about was the late ‘60s and early to mid ‘70s. A great deal of development happened during the decade of the 1970s! That is when the real musicians began to arrive in California to stay. Most of the US Bellydance popularity appears to have begun first on the Eastern coast of the US. Also, more dance opportunities for paid professional dancers first developed around the Hollywood/Los Angeles and in Las Vegas than in San Francisco/Berkeley.
    I do not mean to claim that there were not numerous Bellydance cafes and restaurants that were beginning to open then. There were many. They lasted about as long as it takes to gestate a baby hippopotamus and then closed again with nothing more than a note thumb-tacked to the front door, unpaid bills stored in a card-board shoebox shoved in the broom closet, and no forwarding address. (Sometimes they burned down.)
    …the scheduled dancer stood on the unlit stairs, reading the “Closed” notice with her garment bag full of costuming slung over her shoulder and disappointment on her carefully made-up face as she batted her false eyelashes to keep back her angry tears. She was so unimportant in the scheme of things that nobody thought to cancel her appearance…
    It became apparent to me that dancing in a “nightclub” or northern California restaurant was not the best of all a professional dancer’s aspirations during the ‘70s. So many places opened and closed in jig time that we seldom mention them anymore because dancing in a deli or cafe didn’t seem much more “professional” to most of us than dancing in a traveling snake-oil road show. Still, we had our hopes and pride in our dance.
    I would not include the decades of the ‘80s and ‘90s to a list titled “Golden Era of Bellydance” either, but rather a “Popularization Era”, while Bert Balladine often referred to those decades as “The Era of Bellydance Imperialism” –because of the many changes that we westerners self-righteously added to its form and technique.
    Najia

  4. No Gravatar
    Kamala Almanzar

    Sep 1, 2011 - 03:09:44

    I feel very fortunate to have been in that little window of opportunity. Thank you for the clarification, Najia!

  5. No Gravatar
    Cassandra Shore

    Sep 1, 2011 - 09:09:19

    I disagree about the venues in San Francisco. None of them were huge gorgeous places, but there was plenty of experience to be had working with some fine musicians, or recorded music if you liked. There was a price to pay for it- no money and one really had to work 6 or 7 nights a week just to stay in rent, food, and gas money. I arrived in SF from Minnesota in 1975, and the was The Plaka Taverna (not long-lived) The Greek Taverna, The Bagdad, The Casbah, Powell Street Station, and soon after, Pasha’s. John Compton danced at Finnochio’s across the street from the Casbah…not a usual gig, I know. Still, I moved to the Bay area to get experience and training and wouldn’t trade my experiences there for anything. When I moved back to MN, it was to work with a Greek band, and then with Arabic music on cassettes and CD’s when that place changed hands.  Sometimes owners came to Bert’s classes looking for performers! I had so much good education from musicians like Fadil Shahin, Jalal Takesh and his brother Salah, as well as Aida, Saida, Amina and Stasia and the many other teaching resources in the city, the East bay and Marin. That time spent learning stimulated my curiosity about the Arab world, culture , and music in a way no other could have and I am grateful to have been lucky enough to have brushed shoulders with all those generous folks.

  6. No Gravatar
    Sadira

    Sep 4, 2011 - 01:09:19

    Well I always considered myself to be in the “golden age of bellydance”; perhaps because I don’t understand the dance scene of today which is mostly copying other Egyptian dancer’s choreography, all looking alike, or throwing everything in, calling it Tribal and not understanding one bit about rhythym, Arabic or Middle Eastern music, songs, or more then a few calibrated steps repeated over and over.
     I didn’t know the sixties; but the early 70’s and on.  What I hated was the politics involved, the Jamilla students and performers v.s. anyone not decreed by her to be a teacher or dancer.  Ethnic vs. cabaret.  Dancing for onions?  I never danced for an onion, or a string of beads, I did dance for free a lot!!!!
     I worked hard to study the music, songs, composers of music and the right movements for the right music.  In those days, you had to tell the musicians what songs you wanted for your dance (if you were lucky to be asked), what tempo, what rhythym.  It was important I felt to known the regional differences in dance, costuming, history and style.
     I do remember when it all seemed to start deteriating and the Broadway nightclubs had no more then 2 or 3 customers inside ; and the dancers were not of the caliber as before.  I remember hearing Fadil Shaheen, owner and musician at the Casbah remark, “pretty soon the dancers will be paying me to dance at the club”…as the fee’s for dancing began to drop and student dancers danced for free dinners or $10.00 with the result of excellent professional performers losing their spots or their livelihood from dance.
      People were able to make a living with dance and teaching then….but it was your whole world and you had to constantly compete, think up new venues, or make your own venue.
      I also remember Bert saying “you must always show your audience that you are a lady, dance from  your heart and express your thanks to your audience and your musicians as well”. 
      Well, Najia what a strange trip it has all been, eh!  stealing from a song lyric about that time.  Oh, the things we saw……

  7. No Gravatar
    Selena Kareena

    Sep 20, 2011 - 01:09:47

    Never say Die! Never Give up! It’s still not too late. Perhaps it just wasn’t your time.  As a late comer to The Scene, i’m in my late 50’s and just now stattingto knock on “Those Doors” PLUS, I live in a VERY small town with little to NO Dance Venues, but for every NO I get there is another Door to knock on!~I WILL accomplish My DREAM! Whether they like me or not, Guess What, I’m NOT Going AWAY any time soon! (In Sha lah).  I may have to travel or Do whatever it takes to fullfil My Fantasy to Live my ‘Golden Age” Mark my words, If One Dancer can Di it another Dancer can Do it. We have All felt those moments of disappointment and i appreciate what you are saying, Najia, but remember, Never Give up on your DREAMS!Never!

Click and type in the comment box to add to this discussion. If you want to see an avatar for yourself, set up an avatar at http://www.Gravatar.com

 

Gilded Serpent

MaryEllen Donald